“I just don’t read
books anymore.”
“I don’t either,
between work and everything else, I just can’t seem to concentrate.”
“I still read…”
“Yeah, but you
never stopped. You never fell out of the habit.”
The above conversation took place between myself and two
of my friends last month. Neither of them has completely read a book for
pleasure in the last several years. Both are highly educated, driven, smart,
creative individuals for whom reading for pleasure had once been a regular part
of their lives. They’ve simply stopped as their lives have gotten busy and
their professional challenges more demanding. This surprised me, as one of
these gents in particular was once a great reader of fiction.
Interestingly, both believe that the amount of time they
spend in front of a screen in both professional and personal capacity has
eroded their ability to concentrate on reading a book, especially novels. It isn’t
just the noisy distraction of a screen, though—both also felt that the way they
read for their jobs, quickly scanning large chunks of information to pull out
relevant pieces, has destroyed their ability to read sentence to sentence,
paragraph to paragraph and get lost in a story. They were envious of me, they
said, because I never stopped reading, no matter what else was going on. I
commented that if I want to remain creatively viable as a writer, constant
reading is a must. Upon later reflection, while this is true to a degree, I
don’t think my need to always be reading a book is primarily driven by writing.
It predates my writing life, and when I stopped writing in the 90s for a while,
it didn’t affect my reading. If I stopped writing tomorrow I don’t think it
would change my reading habits at all, aside from perhaps freeing up my time a
bit more.
I find myself wondering how many variations of the above
conversation have taken place in America over the last decade. From a personal
perspective, the people I know who read for pleasure (especially fiction) are
almost all also writers. There are a few exceptions, and of course my
experience is not universal. Yet I don’t think it’s controversial to say that books
are not part of the wider culture conversation currently. It’s not that people
don’t read, it’s that the hot take culture doesn’t lend itself to the nuanced
discussion a good book generally requires. And with the rare exception of
something like Harry Potter, books don’t reach widely across the diversity of
American culture. It’s not that books are not important: to those that read,
they most certainly are. But does a book—let’s limit this to fiction for the
sake of argument—ever prompt water cooler talk anymore? I’m just spitballing; I
could be off on this. My viewpoint is informed by those I interact with and
what I observe, which by definition is a small slice of pie.
Let’s pretend for a moment that this is largely true as
far as fiction goes. As anyone who has had a conversation about books with me
can attest, one thing that really gets under my skin in much contemporary
fiction is the writer as protagonist and, related, the act of writing and books
themselves as meta-commentary. There are exceptions to the rule, but in general
I find this lazy and narcistic. It too often betrays a lack of interest (or
confidence) in exploring the wider world by the author. Write what you know? Authors
can remain truthful to emotional experience without making every major
character a writer.
I find such an approach limiting, but if a significant
part of your audience is other authors or people otherwise heavily involved in
writing/publication culture, then maybe I’m barking up the wrong tree. I mean,
why not write for your audience? If books aren’t going to engage with the
larger culture milieu anymore, then why not engage directly with the subculture
they belong to? At the end of the day, this is an academic argument, of
course—if you read, you are going to read what interests you, and if you write,
you’re going to write what interests you. As it should be. And yet when I read
a book like Imagine
Me Gone, one of the best, most heart-wrenching novels I’ve read in some
time, I’m reminded of what a book that speaks to the wider experience of
everyday life can be. A book populated by people, broken though they may be,
who live and breathe the same air we do, who are real. It’s a book that I think could find a wide appreciation
across a diverse spectrum of cultural experience, but I wonder how it might even
find its audience. If any “genre” of fiction has been hurt by this cultural
shift, it’s books which don’t have a genre. Books that are, simply, fiction. Now
maybe Imagine Me Gone sold just
fine—I discovered it via a random best books of the year list—I don’t even know
what would be considered selling fine in 2017, and as a reader I don’t care.
But I am interested in the ability of a book to find a diverse audience, and to
do that it almost has to become part of the cultural conversation (and most
likely be published by a larger publication house who can properly promote it
to said diverse audiences.) And when does that happen with fiction books these
days? Even a book like The Underground
Railroad, which with its critical acclaim and multiple high-profile awards
is the most recent example I can think of, did not appear to really become part
of the larger cultural conversation—and I would argue probably many of those
who did opine about it didn’t actually read it. (I’ve yet to read it and
therefore have no opinion on it as a work of fiction, though I’ve enjoyed other
books by Colson Whitehead.)
“I just don’t read
books anymore.” This line scares me and makes me incredibly sad. Perhaps
both emotions are overreactions. Books do not own a monopoly on storytelling,
after all. I’m not a hardcore gamer, but I do enjoy the occasional video game
and the evolution of storytelling in games is, I think, one of the most
interesting aspects of pop culture in the last twenty years. Games themselves
have a novel-like storylines, and involving the player in the story and having
their choices dictate the storyline in some cases is a fascinating case of
technology changing the relationship between author and reader. That’s just one
example, there are others. As a species, we will never not seek out
stories—simply having an awareness of existence in this universe means we will
create and share stories until humanity winks out (which I hope is a hell of a
long way down the road still.) Maybe it’s not a big deal that more and more
folks don’t have room for pleasurable reading in their life. Maybe that itch is
being scratched in other ways. I truly hope so.
Well, I still read books. Lots of ‘em. And what you have
here is my annual overview of the pleasurable reading I did in 2017. This is my
fourth year (
2014,
2015,
2016)
doing this and each year this post grows longer because I don’t know how to
shut up. If brevity is the soul of wit, I’m clearly witless. I started writing
this Thanksgiving weekend and here we finally are.
Read in 2017
The Wilding, Benjamin
Pearcy
The Fisherman, John
Langan
A Brief History of
Time, Stephen Hawking
SPQR: A History of
Ancient Rome, Mary Beard
Ready Player One,
Ernest Cline
The Ruins,
Scott Smith
Born to Run,
Bruce Springsteen
Shirley Jackson: A
Rather Haunted Life, Ruth Franklin
Beautiful Children,
Charles Bock
The Night Marchers
and Other Strange Tales, Daniel Braum
Tapping the Source,
Kem Nunn
Life in Motion: An
Unlikely Ballerina, Misty Copeland
Ramsey Campbell,
Probably, Ramsey Campbell
Dear Sweet Filthy
World, Caitlin Kiernan
Aurora, Kim
Stanley Robinson
U2 at the End of
the World, Bill Flanagan
The Wide,
Carnivorous Sky, John Langan
Cast a Cold Eye,
Alan Ryan
So Deadly, So
Perverse: 50 Years of Italian Giallo Films: Volume 1 1963-1973, Troy
Howarth
So Deadly, So
Perverse: 50 Years of Italian Giallo Films: Volume 2 1974-2013, Troy
Howarth
The Ocean at the
End of the Lane, Neil Gaiman
American Tabloid,
James Ellroy
Sing Me Your Scars,
Damien Angelica Walters
Paper Tigers, Damien
Angelica Walters
One Minute to
Midnight: Kennedy, Khrushchev and Castro on the Brink of Nuclear War, Michael
Dobbs
Borne, Jeff
VanderMeer
Ghosts of Seattle
Past, compiled/edited by Jaimee Garbacik
The Missing,
Sarah Langan
The Best Horror of
the Year, Volume Nine, edited by Ellen Datlow
Year’s Best Weird
Fiction, Volume Three, edited by Simon Strantzas
Imagine Me Gone,
Adam Haslett
The Girl on the
Train, Paula Hawkins
The Doll Who Ate
His Mother, Ramsey Campbell
Sleeping Beauties,
Stephen King and Owen King
Paperbacks from
Hell: The Twisted History of '70s and '80s Horror Fiction, Grady Hendrix
Death by Black
Hole: And Other Cosmic Quandaries, Neil deGrasse Tyson
Everything That's
Underneath: A Collection of Weird and Horror Tales, Kristi DeMeester
Strange Weather,
Joe Hill
Hit So Hard: A
Memoir, Patty Schemel
The Illumination,
Kevin Brockemeier
Let’s begin at the top of the peak: Kristi DeMeester’s
collection
Everything
That’s Underneath was not only my favorite weird fiction read of the
year, it might have been my favorite read period. The current “golden age” of
weird fiction has started to devolve a little too often into a sameness of
style and approach (the Lovecraft pastiches in particular bringing back
diminishing returns to this reader) and DeMeester’s strong, original and
visceral voice is a welcome reversal of this trend. I don’t write too many
Goodreads
reviews, but DeMeester’s work so shook me to the core and inspired me that I posted
the following:
This is a stunning,
darkly beautiful collection of tales. But be warned: these are not
"easy" tales to read. DeMeester has little use for the standard weird
tale tropes. Even at their most metaphorical, her tales explore, often rawly,
themes of abuse (physical and emotional), sexuality, transformation, matriarchy
and misogyny. This is writing that is close to the heart even when laden with
fantastic imagery. Part of DeMeester's gift is the matter-of-fact presentation
of this imagery; never does the reader feel she's writing to show off. There is
a fierce intelligence to these tales. Some of these tales are darkly erotic,
reminding me of the early work of Livia Llewellyn, but DeMeester's voice is
uniquely her own and it's refreshing and inspiring to this reader to see horror
and eroticism blended so deftly and intelligently. I was also reminded at times
of Hellraiser and the longing to transform and transcend the flesh. I was
deeply moved by many of these tales, something that has become increasingly
rare in the weird tale arena. I can't wait to see where Kristi DeMeester
goes--wherever it is, I will eagerly follow.
All of this is true, and yet it doesn’t even begin to
capture the power of these tales. In 2011 Livia Llewellyn published her debut
collection, Engines of Desire. The
first two stories in that collection, “Horses” and “At the Edge of Ellensburg,”
hit me on a deep, visceral level; they were the most impactful—and
inspiring—stories I’d read in years. Those two stories feature the weird tale
at its most powerful and charging; they are dangerous stories. Almost every single tale in Everything That’s Underneath works on that level. They engage the
mind and soul, ready to destroy and transform, unconcerned with whether you are
ready for the impact. They don’t fuck around. They are dangerous. This book is a towering achievement, all the more
impressive for being (I believe) a debut. Why do I always find time to read?
Because a work like this enriches my life beyond compare. This is my church,
and DeMeester’s work an altar before which I kneel. Llewellyn’s subsequent
works have generally not been to my taste; I truly hope the same doesn’t happen
with DeMeester. For now, I cannot wait to read more.
I could repeat pretty much all of the above when talking
about Damien Angelica Walters’s Sing Me
Your Scars collection. From my Goodreads review:
What a darkly
beautiful collection of stories! Tearing, stitching, reweaving...these stories
of transformation, defiance, loss and sorrow are told with skill and openness.
Transcending narrow genre labels, graceful even at their most disturbing, the
tales in this collection will linger long in my memory and, I am certain,
reward frequent revisiting in the future. I was not familiar with Damien
Angelica Walters' work prior to reading Sing Me Your Scars, but I will now
eagerly seek out her past and future projects. Personal favorites include
Sugar, Sin and Nonesuch Harry; Girl, With Coin; Paskutinis Iliuzijia (The Last
Illusion) and The Taste of Tears in a Raindrop but every story is magical.
Absolutely wonderful.
Inspired by Sing Me
Your Scars, I sought out Walters’s novel Paper Tigers. Novels are of course a different beast (heh heh), and
while Paper Tigers couldn’t match the
impact of Sing Me Your Scars, I found
it to be a compelling, atmospheric novel with a very-well defined central
character. Only a couple of credibility-straining moments which snapped me out
of the world Paper Tigers creates
keeps it from being a complete success, but if you’re on the lookout for a
moody, dreamlike ghost story it’s well worth your time.
Before I move on to the rest of my 2017 book thoughts, I
want to say something that I honestly don’t know how to say well, so forgive
any clumsiness: It was tremendously refreshing and revitalizing to discover two
strong female voices in DeMeester and Walters this year. It’s not that their
stories are completely defined by their gender—they are both too talented for
that and I refuse to reduce their work to something so specific—but I do think
it informs their perspective and adds a much-needed dimension to the weird tale
in 2018. It’s not that there aren’t other female writers working in this
territory, but there are nowhere near enough, and the vitality of DeMeester and
Walters’s work is a refreshing antidote to the staleness that is creeping in
more often to the weird tale of late. Their work moved me profoundly, and
inspired me on a multitude of levels. If you are in the least bit curious,
please consider purchasing and supporting the small presses that give a
platform to not only their voices, but the voices of many on the margins of the
genre.
I mentioned Imagine
Me Gone in the intro above, and it is hands down one of the most
emotionally moving novels I’ve read in a long while. This is the last time I’ll
quote from one of my own Goodreads reviews—I only wrote three all year—but the
below, written while the last pages were still echoing in me, hasn’t lessened a
bit with time:
Heartbreaking,
beautiful, frightening...this is the story of mental illness and the strange,
wonderful and tragic interlocking of lives that we label with the simple term
"family." I love this family so much. I finished this book in tears.
Rarely have I read a book that sits so close to the bone. This is the most
human of novels, an astounding achievement.
It truly is the most human of novels, a story that pushed
me to tears so many times and had me laughing out loud at others. Profoundly
moving, deeply sad, heartbreakingly beautiful and just so goddamned real. Imagine Me Gone is everything great fiction should be.
I’m not sure how Kem Nunn’s 1984 debut novel Tapping the Source ended up on my radar,
but I checked it out from the local library (support them, friends!) while in
the throes of one my periodic “I have no idea what I want to read” episodes.
Knowing next to nothing about surfing culture, I found it a dark piece of California
noir that, while certainly dated in some respects, was still quite compelling.
Turns out the movie Point Break, a completely empty, dumb film that I have a
tremendous fondness for, was “based” on Tapping
the Source but let me tell you—they have nothing in common beyond character
names. Tapping the Source has its
faults, but stupidity isn’t one of them…I wouldn’t call The Girl on the Train stupid either, but I’m genuinely curious what
the fuss is about. The novel clearly connected with a lot of people, and while
I found it a breezy enough read, it seemed to me a very average novel at best. Not
bad, not good, just kind of meh. What was it about The Girl on the Train that resonated with so many folks—it seems
like one of those increasingly rare fiction novels that crossed over to a wide
audience?...
The chill of late winter found me in biography mode. Shirley Jackson: A Rather Haunted Life
is a long-overdue, exhaustively researched biography of the author of three of
the greatest pieces of fiction ever written: the novels The Haunting of Hill House and We
Have Always Lived in the Castle and the short story “The Lottery.” A
complex figure who struggled with the social mores of her time and a husband
who was an ass more often than not, Jackson’s work has not always found the
appreciative audience it deserves, especially outside of “The Lottery.” Seeing
it all back in print and this excellent biography receiving wide notice warms
my heart, I just wish she was here to appreciate it…I read Bruce Springsteen’s
autobiography Born to Run during a
personally difficult time. I appreciate Springsteen but don’t consider myself a
fan (Tunnel of Love being the
exception, it is a master clinic in nuanced adult songwriting); however, his
storytelling mastery in Born to Run
lead me to dive back into his catalog for the first time since my adolescence.
I connected with the sense of hard-won hope and struggle in those songs. They
brought the belief that better days could still be ahead at a time when I
desperately needed it. Springsteen is a funny guy and I enjoyed spending time
with him in Born to Run…
Legend? Ramsey Campbell is damn sure one in my book. I
covered
The Doll Who Ate His Mother
extensively in
Danse
Macabre’s Horror Novels 36 Years Later; I won’t rehash here.
Ramsey Campbell, Probably is a
collection of Campbell’s nonfiction from throughout his long career. Perhaps my
expectations were too high, but I was quite disappointed. The presentation was
chopped up and random, it really seemed like an editor just dumped the scraps
of paper from Campbell’s filing cabinet on the desk, stapled it together and
called it a book. Campbell has written plenty of excellent nonfiction, and
you’ll find some of it buried in
Probably,
but the poor presentation and lack of coherence make it hard to recommend, even
to diehard fans…I’m not sure if Neil Gaiman is a legend, but outside of perhaps
George R.R. Martin he’s the most well-known author the fantasy field has
produced in the last 25 years. His work on
Sandman
has had a profound and lasting influence in my life, but I’ve often struggled
to connect with his novels; only
Coraline
and
American Gods worked on any level
for me. So it was with no expectations I came across a used copy of
The Ocean at the End of the Lane and
decided to give it a shot. And am I ever glad I did: easily my favorite Gaiman
novel, it’s a heartfelt work all the more powerful for its brevity (I read it
over the course of two of my daughter’s swim practices.)…Caitlin Kiernan is a
legend to some of us, but
Dear Sweet
Filthy World is not one of her stronger collections. It’s not bad but pales
next superior collections like
To Charles
Fort, With Love. If you’re new to her work, start there. Hardcore fans will
find plenty to like in
Dear Sweet Filthy
World but casual readers may struggle to connect…
Giallo
cinema has long been a passion of mine, and Troy Howarth’s two volume set
So Deadly, So Perverse is an essential
companion for hardcore fans and newcomers alike. I particularly appreciated the
approach—rather than a more academic overview, both books consist of reviews of
every giallo film as per Howarth’s definition. One can always quibble at the
edges—“why this film and not that one?”—but every essential giallo film is
covered here, and a ton more besides. Pour some J&B, slip into something
comfortable (preferably with black gloves) and enjoy—just hide all the knives…I
had high hopes for
Ghosts of Seattle
Past, but it disappointed—anyone not already familiar with the cultural
history of the area will find a disjointed, random book, albeit one that has a
couple of choice interviews. A for effort, C- for execution…The endless photos
of classic horror paperback covers from the 70s and 80s makes up for
Paperbacks from Hell’s uneven text. The
text would have benefitted from a better thematic framework and a more in-depth
approach would have been appreciated by this reader (subtitling this a history
of 70s and 80s horror fiction is false advertising.) That aside, there’s
nothing terrible about it, and those pictures! Damn! Recommended as a nostalgia
kick for fans of the genre…I have the utmost respect for Neil deGrasse Tyson
but his written work too often makes me miss Carl Sagan. Neil’s touch is
somehow leaden, even though he has a playful sense of humor. It’s not fair to
compare anyone to Sagan, I know. We desperately need rational voices that can
bring science to the masses, and Neil deGrasse Tyson is our best emissary right
now, so his work transcends whatever minor style critiques I may have of it...
King of the Hill: Quiet year for Stephen King, no solo
works but instead we get two co-written books. The first,
Gwendy's Button Box, I surprisingly haven’t read yet (as a hardcore
Constant Reader, I generally pick up all major King works on the day they come
out.) No particular reason, I just didn’t feel strongly drawn to it. I’ll
probably get around to it in 2018. The other novel, co-written with his son
Owen King, is
Sleeping Beauties. I
shared
my
thoughts on Sleeping Beauties
back in October so I’ll not rehash here…Joe Hill followed up last year’s novel
The Fireman with a collection of four
novellas,
Strange Weather. The title
is an intentionally obvious nod to his father’s first four novella collection,
Different Seasons, and this homage is
either charming or annoying, depending on your wiring. Maybe not the wisest
move, as I found
Strange Weather to
be uneven and even tentative at times. Only the first story, “Snapshot,” really
worked, and even it felt top-heavy with several eye-rolling, “are you serious?”
plot choices. There was one way in which I was very much reminded of
Different Seasons: in that collection,
the second tale “Apt Pupil” was, to my young mind, one of the most disturbing
stories I’d read up to that point. I was fascinated and deeply uncomfortable
with the exploration of Nazi attraction, concentration camp fetishism, random
killing and guns. Not a hint of anything supernatural. The second tale in
Strange Weather, “Loaded,” provided a
similar level of uncomfortableness, though not fascination, as Hill struggles
to come to term with our current culture’s gun fetishism. An understandable
goal, but the tale was thoroughly unpleasant to read (which I’m sure was
intentional) and I still don’t know if it worked as a piece of art or not. I
admire the intent if not the results. I also hated the story and felt depressed
every time I picked up the book until it was finished. “Loaded” is probably
deserving of its own post at some point as I’m still struggling to articulate
how I feel about it.
Strange Weather
is not a strong collection given Hill’s talent, but thanks to “Loaded,” it will
probably stay with me far longer than it really should…
Pleasant surprises are the best. I didn’t go into John
Langan’s novel The Fisherman with any
great expectations as my familiarity with his work was limited to a couple of
short stories which weren't to my personal taste. But my oh my, was The Fisherman ever to my taste! A fantastic
novel full of believable characters even as the circumstances get more and more
Lovecraftian strange through the tale’s progression. Fantastic pacing too. So
much did I enjoy it I decided to give Langan’s short stories another crack with
the collection The Wide, Carnivorous Sky
and this time many of them stuck. Recommended for fans of the genre…Borne was another pleasant surprise.
Post-apocalyptic weird fantasy isn’t really my cup of tea, and after the first
ten pages I thought I was going to abandon it, and then for whatever reason Borne just clicked and I blew through
the rest of it. VanderMeer’s Southern
Reach Trilogy is the highwater mark of weird fiction this decade; following
it up with a smaller, more intimate tale was smart and ultimately successful.
Curious to see where he goes next…
The Illumination
has two awesome ideas driving it: randomly one Friday night all pain started to
shine brightly and continues to do so forever after, allowing all of us to see
each other’s pain. Second, a private journal of daily one sentence love notes,
written by a husband to his wife, passes through many hands following a fatal
car accident. Both are strong, beautiful ideas (I was especially taken by the daily
love notes which capture the intimacy in the mundane of long-term
relationships) but unfortunately, after a strong start, Brockmeier can’t drive
them anywhere interesting. The episodic approach could have worked, but his
protagonists and their settings get duller as book goes on, and when he dropps
the author on a book tour character in towards the end, it just falls apart. So
much potential, but the book doesn’t get there. Try his other novel The Brief History of the Dead, it’s much
stronger…My friend handed me a copy of Ready
Player One and said I had to read it. Good on him, because I loved it. I
guess there is a movie coming out and the book seems quite popular currently,
so good for Cline. If I’d read a plot summary of the book I would never have
touched it; this is why you need friends to recommend books. Algorithms cannot
do so as successfully, friends will turn you on to something you would not have
tried otherwise…I love a bleak novel where you are fairly certain from the
early pages the fate awaiting the characters ain’t gonna be a happy one, and The Ruins delivered in spades. Absolutely
loved it and now I want to read more of Scott Smith’s work…Sarah Langan seems
to have disappeared but I’ve enjoyed all three of her novels, with The Missing the strongest of the three
plot-wise (Audrey’s Door has slightly
better characterization.) Yes, it’s nothing new, and you can see echoes of
classic King, Straub, et. al. But those three chords still ring true in the
hands of a talented player, and Langan is talented. To my knowledge she hasn’t
published any novels or collections since 2007 and I sure hope she hasn’t
walked away from writing. It would be a loss for the horror genre…
My thoughts regarding
American
Tabloid can be found
here;
James Ellroy is a thorny treasure…
Cast A
Cold Eye is an enjoyable quiet horror read from the early 80s…
Beautiful Children is a dark, fucked-up
novel and I mean that as a compliment—the vibe is very
Requiem for a Dream (one of my all-time favorite novels) so don’t
say you weren’t warned…The tales that make up Daniel Braum’s
The Night Marchers show promise but aren’t
all the way there yet…
The Wilding has
its moments, at times reminiscent of
Deliverance
(minus any squealing pigs), one odd character choice throws the book off a
bit and keeps it from achieving greatness but it’s still a worthwhile read with
the central characters well developed...
And with that, dear friends, I’m calling it good. I
realize there are a couple of non-fiction works and anthologies I didn’t opine
on, I hope you can live with the disappointment (and if you can’t, email me and
I’ll be happy to jabber on.) Please consider supporting your local library,
local independent bookseller, and small presses to the best of your capability
if you don’t already do so. All of us read and write because we passionately love
to do so, and the more channels that can remain open, the more voices have a
chance to be heard. See ya in 2018!